Can a smartwatch count every step correctly? The short answer is: not always, but it is usually good enough for everyday fitness.
Most smartwatches use a small motion sensor called an accelerometer. This sensor notices movement in different directions. The watch’s software then decides whether each movement is a step. (support.google.com)
However, your arm does not always move in the same way as your legs. For example, when you push a shopping cart, carry a child, or hold the handles of a treadmill, your arms may stay still. As a result, the watch may miss some steps. On the other hand, activities such as brushing your teeth or driving on a rough road may sometimes add steps because your wrist is moving. (support.garmin.com)
Research also shows that step counts can change depending on the device and where it is worn. A recent large review found that wrist devices often reported different numbers from devices worn on the hip or ankle. Even different consumer devices may show a difference of several hundred steps in one day. (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) Another major review found that wearable devices sometimes counted about 9% fewer steps or up to 12% more steps than the real number. (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
You can improve accuracy by wearing your watch firmly but comfortably. Check that your height, age, and other personal information are correct in the app. You should also choose the correct wrist in the settings. Some watches can be calibrated during an outdoor walk or run. (support.google.com)
A smartwatch is useful for watching general changes. If your daily count rises from 4,000 to 7,000, you are probably becoming more active. However, do not worry about small differences. Think of the number as a helpful estimate, not a perfect answer.